Prosecuting Attorney for Elkhart County

In accordance with the Indiana Rules of Professional Conduct, the Office of the Prosecuting Attorney is releasing the following information to address the recent publicity and false information being disseminated relating to an Officer Involved Fatal Shooting in Elkhart County last week.  To those members of our community that have refrained from engaging in spreading speculative information, your willingness to allow the investigative process into the victim’s death to proceed in a manner that protects the integrity and professionalism of a law enforcement investigation is truly respected and appreciated.

As was previously indicated, within a very short time after the shooting early Sunday morning, February 8, 2026, the Elkhart County Homicide Unit, a multi-jurisdictional investigative group of law enforcement officers that specializes in death investigations in Elkhart County, is investigating the event.  The Homicide Unit utilizes numerous local, state, federal, public and private, experts as part of their investigative process as is necessary to complete their responsibilities.  This process is currently underway and has been able to reliably corroborate several facts pertinent to the case.  However, there are significant facts and items of evidence that are still awaiting forensic analysis that are absolutely necessary for the full determination of whether the shooting was justified under the law of Indiana.

The Grand Jury of Elkhart County was convened on September 2, 2025, by the Elkhart County Circuit Court at the request of Prosecuting Attorney Vicki Elaine Becker. The Grand Jury heard evidence regarding the facts and circumstances surrounding allegations that Elkhart County Clerk Christopher Anderson, and one of his Chief Deputy Clerks Carol Smith, approved the expenditure of public funds without proper authorization. In September 2024, the Elkhart County Sheriff’s Office and the Indiana State Board of Accounts were notified of several concerns with certain clerk employees receiving payment for hours that they did not actually work, and that the practice had been going on for several years. In June of 2025, the SBOA issued public report 25840C summarizing non-compliance with Elkhart County Policy as well as Indiana law by Anderson and Smith and documenting that Anderson was aware of the long-standing practice of paying supervisors for 80 hours even though they only had to work 72. Further illustrating the endorsement of this practice, Smith had sent an email to a newly appointed Supervisor of the Clerk’s Office in August of 2022 advising that “You get paid for 80 hours even though you only work 72. The idea is the Supervisor is usually first in and last out, so it’s just a bit of extra for the Supervisor taking on the job.” The Elkhart County Sheriff’s Office conducted a criminal investigation into the same allegation to determine if the alleged conduct violated the criminal laws of the State of Indiana.

The Elkhart County Homicide Unit has arrested one Franklin Elmore, Jr. (29), and one Cheyenne Elmore (27), both of Elkhart, for the August 3, 2025, murder of Franklin Elmore’s six-year-old child residing with them at their residence on County Road 22, Elkhart, Indiana. Although the initial report was that the child had allegedly “hit himself” and was unresponsive, emergency treatment providers at Elkhart General Hospital observed that some of the injuries apparently sustained by the victim were not believed to be self-inflicted, including a traumatic brain injury and a punctured lung. Further investigation demonstrated that Cheyenne Elmore had previously complained to Franklin Elmore, Jr., about the behavior of the six-year-old child to Franklin Elmore, Jr., and that Franklin Elmore, Jr., and Cheyenne Elmore would discipline the child by forcing him to engage in lengthy physical exercise and “whoop” him with a belt or a hand. Investigators observed numerous bruises and abrasions on the body of the child after his death. The events that occurred immediately before his death reflect that both Franklin and Cheyenne Elmore were home with the child at approximately 8:45 pm when Franklin Elmore, Jr., attacked the child in his “playroom.” Shortly thereafter, the child became unresponsive and later died after emergency transport to the hospital.